Astronomy & Science

Does Dark Energy Change Over Time?

Sky&Telescope -

Scientists are considering whether the mysterious “force” accelerating the universe’s expansion changes with time.

Of late there’s been some scientific ado over a small but notable conflict in measurements of the universe’s expansion rate. The present rate, called the Hubble constant or H0 (pronounced “H-naught”), connects the redshift in an object’s spectra to its physical distance. It also tells us the universe’s age and size, as well as the density required to make the universe geometrically flat.

It is, in short, a rather important number.

Hubble constant measurements

This plot shows some representative measurements of the expansion rate of today's universe, known as the Hubble constant. The figure includes three values derived from measurements of the cosmic microwave background (left side of the plot) and four values derived from "nearby" objects (right side of plot). The values presented here are the bare-bones results from each study; any of these values can be made more precise by combining information from multiple data sets.
Ana Aceves / Monica Young

The universe’s expansion was one of the biggest discoveries of the 20th century. But after nearly a century of study, astronomers still don’t entirely agree on how fast the current expansion is. Those using the cosmic microwave background favor a value of about 65 kilometers per second per megaparsec (km/s/Mpc, where a megaparsec is 3.26 million light-years). Those using supernovae and other, more nearby cosmic tools home in on a value of about 73 km/s/Mpc (see graph).

The discrepancy is reminiscent of another debate toward the turn of the 21st century, with one side hotly advocating around 50 km/s/Mpc and the other roughly 100 km/s/Mpc. Careful work by Wendy Freedman (University of Chicago) and others using the Hubble Space Telescope resolved that controversy.

The current disagreement might be merely a matter of analysis and assumptions (maybe even a cosmic void). However, Freedman notes that part of the solution to the previous predicament was the mind-exploding discovery that, over the last half of cosmic history, the universe’s expansion has been accelerating. Something identified by the placeholder term “dark energy” fuels this acceleration. Although we don’t know what dark energy is yet, a favored view is that it’s some sort of energy inherent to space itself. If so, then as space expands, dark energy will increase with it and maintain the same density, instead of diluting out.

Could new physics be behind the current conflict, too?

Universe's expansion explained

The expansion of the universe began with the Big Bang, nearly 14 billion years ago. After a brief spurt of inflation, the expansion rate slowed, then several billion years later (estimates vary) acceleration kicked in when dark energy dominated gravity.
Nobel Prize Foundation

Gong-Bo Zhao (Chinese Academy of Sciences and University of Portsmouth, UK) and colleagues decided to explore this question. They investigated whether the latest controversy could be due to an evolving dark energy, one whose density not only changes with time but also changes in the way its density changes with time.

In mathematical terms, if dark energy’s density remains constant, then its equation of state, w, is equal to −1. This would make it the cosmological constant — the lambda (Λ) in the lambda-cold-dark-matter (ΛCDM) paradigm, the official name of our modern cosmological framework. Observations support this value, with wiggle room. If w is greater than −1 (−0.9, et cetera), however, then dark energy’s density slowly decreases as the universe expands. If w is less than −1, then the density increases with expansion.

What Zhao’s team did was to check if, instead of staying one value, the equation of state actually changes over cosmic time, morphing across a range of w values. Amassing a large, diverse set of others’ observations, the team cautiously analyzed it to see what kind of cosmos the data might describe. Writing August 28th in Nature Astronomy, the authors conclude that it is possible to relieve the H0 tension with a dynamic dark energy, one whose equation of state oscillates above and below the −1 value. However, the slight favoritism for this solution in their analysis is not statistically strong enough to prove it’s the right answer.

The nice thing is, more data will solve this mystery. The team points to the upcoming Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) survey, which aims to begin creating a 3D cosmic map in 2018.


References: G.-B. Zhao et al. “Dynamical Dark Energy in Light of the Latest Observations.” Nature Astronomy. August 28, 2017.

Did the solar eclipse whet your astronomy appetite? Feed it with a subscription to Sky & Telescope.

The post Does Dark Energy Change Over Time? appeared first on Sky & Telescope.

Canon Clip-In Filters from Astronomik

Sky&Telescope -


AstronomikFiltersAstronomik now produces clip-in filters for Canon EOS M-series mirrorless cameras. Prices start at €139 (about $175) for a CLS Clip-Filter. Designed to fit between most Canon lenses and its M1 and M3 camera series detectors, the filters' placement ensure minimal distortions to stars throughout your images. These filters offer the same specialized passbands as the firm's DSLR clip-in filters, including clear (CLS) with UV/IR blocking, narrowband wavelengths such as Hα, O III, S II, and many other passbands particularly useful when shooting with modified mirrorless Canon cameras.'s New Product Showcase is a reader service featuring innovative equipment and software of interest to amateur astronomers. The descriptions are based largely on information supplied by the manufacturers or distributors. Sky & Telescope assumes no responsibility for the accuracy of vendors statements. For further information contact the manufacturer or distributor. Announcements should be sent to Not all announcements will be listed.

The post Canon Clip-In Filters from Astronomik appeared first on Sky & Telescope.


Subscribe to aggregator - Astronomy & Science